HILLSBOROUGH MP SLAMS ISLE OF MAN GOVERNMENT'S REFUSAL TO BACK LANDMARK TRUTH LAW
• Ian Byrne says the Island should learn from decades of injustice after Hillsborough
• Chief Minister Chris Thomas is urged to consider a Manx duty of candour
• Summerland families still seek answers more than 50 years after the fire
• Outgoing Attorney General Walter Wannenburgh KC refused the latest fresh-inquest request
Part Seven of The Armadillo’s investigation into accountability on the Isle of Man probes political procrastination on truth and transparency. The latest story follows our warning that Hillsborough Law may come too late for the £90 million Lord Street case and our report on campaigners’ criticism of the Isle of Man Government’s refusal to back a truth law. In this instalment, UK MP Ian Byrne challenges Manx ministers over candour.
A Hillsborough survivor, who is leading the campaign for a landmark UK truth law, has condemned the Isle of Man Government.
Ian Byrne slammed Manx ministers for their reluctance to introduce equivalent protections.
He warned of the human and financial price of institutions refusing to acknowledge mistakes.
In an exclusive interview, the Liverpool West Derby MP said he was deeply disappointed with Manx delays.
In July, ministers told Tynwald they had no immediate plans for their own version of the Public Office (Accountability) Bill, widely known as Hillsborough Law.
‘When the Isle of Man Government responded with the answer that they wouldn’t implement a Hillsborough Law over there ... it was a huge disappointment,’ Byrne said.
‘They must have seen what had happened over here.
‘I mean the number of state cover-ups, the cost to the taxpayer, the moral cost to people – but also the economic cost.
‘Any government would be looking at that thinking, “Let’s have a look at how this works.”’
Byrne argued that the experiences of bereaved families affected by the 1973 Summerland fire in Douglas - which killed 50 people - should make the Island particularly receptive to stronger safeguards.
Outgoing Attorney General Walter Wannenburgh KC refused the latest application for a fresh inquest in 2025.
But Byrne, who has met Summerland families, urged new Chief Minister Chris Thomas to engage with the families.
‘The parallels between Hillsborough, for me, are hugely, hugely powerful,’ he said.
‘So my message to Chris Thomas and Walter Wannenburgh would be: “You’ve seen what’s happened over here. You’ve got a disaster that happened 50 years ago, and time doesn’t heal them wounds.”’
‘To heal those wounds – and bring closure on Summerland – will be, in my opinion, a complete new inquiry, inquest, whatever the Isle of Man can move forward with the families ...’
He urged the Island to work with the families and agree a process that ‘brings closure to the families’.
The UK Bill, which remains in the House of Lords, proposes duties of candour, transparency and frankness.
Ninety-seven Liverpool supporters lost their lives in the Hillsborough disaster.
Bereaved relatives fought for decades to establish the truth.
Any future Manx criminal offence would not normally apply retrospectively to ongoing cases like the £90 million Lord Street case or the Summerland fire.
But Byrne believes officials should disclose evidence honestly and the state should not exhaust citizens into abandoning legitimate questions.
Previous Armadillo instalments examined the Island’s potential financial exposure and Skipton’s connection to the dispute.
The series also examined Lambert Smith Hampton’s professional record and its public-sector contracts.
Other reports investigated whether the delayed law would come too late for Lord Street and campaigners’ criticism of the Government’s stance.
Chris Thomas, appointed Chief Minister in October, has inherited an opportunity to revisit the Island’s policy, he added.
Byrne’s offer was not simply criticism.
He said he would willingly work with the new Manx Government on a comparable statute.



Comments